Honoring the legacy of Dwight D. Eisenhower, The Eisenhower Institute is a distinguished center for leadership and public policy that prepares the successor generations to perfect the promise of the nation. A distinctive program of Gettysburg College with offices in the heart of the nation's capital and in the historic Gettysburg home once occupied by Dwight and Mamie Eisenhower, the Institute combines top-level dialogue among policy-makers with a premier learning experience for undergraduates.

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Potomac Primary Analysis

Following the Super Tuesday elections, the Democrats had eight primary elections and the Republicans had six. The headline in many of Wednesday’s papers will be something to the effect of the media praising the Obama campaign for winning all of the primaries in Louisiana, Nebraska, Washington, and the U.S. Virgin Islands on Saturday the 9th. He also won the Maine caucus the next day on Sunday February 10th and all of the “Chesapeake Primary” states Maryland, Virginia, and the District of Columbia. This undoubtedly is a large boost in delegates to the Obama campaign and makes him the front runner for the Democratic nomination. To be nominated the democratic candidate needs 2025 delegates. Right now Hilary Clinton has 1220 delegates compared to Obama’s 1275. This may seem like a futile differentiation, but this is the first time in the democratic race that Obama is ahead in the delegate count. Obama’s upswing in the polls can be attributed to his widespread upbeat message espousing hope. Hilary Clinton berated Obama for his lack of policy discussion and his over use of rhetorical flourishes. Clinton’s campaign has seen some shake-ups with Clinton’s campaign manager, Patti Solis Doyle, and deputy campaign manager, Mike Henry, resigning after the election results. What will be interesting to see is how Clinton reshapes her message going into the delegate rich primaries of Texas and Ohio on March 4th. A good indicator will be the Wisconsin open primary on February 19 where 3% of the democratic delegates will be up for grabs. On the Republican side, John McCain has done increasingly well primarily due to the unexpected drop out announcement by former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney. McCain has won the state of Washington over the weekend and on Tuesday swept the “Chesapeake Primary” states. The other contender, former Governor of Arkansas, Mike Huckabee, narrowly won the state of Louisiana (as I predicted) and also won Kansas despite McCain endorsements from former Kansas Senator and Presidential candidate, Bob Dole, and current Senator Sam Brownback. McCain has 843 of the needed 1191 delegates while Huckabee is mathematically out of the race with only 242 delegates. Two things can be learned from the Republican race. I predicted Kansas would go to McCain because of his heavy hitter endorsements. Huckabee narrowly won. This proves endorsements don’t mean much to voters, policy and character do. With Mitt Romney pledging to fight to the end on Tuesday and then dropping out on Thursday that proves that anything can happen in political races despite what pundits, and in this case even candidates, say. I predict that John McCain will win Wisconsin on February 19th and Ohio on March 4th. I will remain staunch in my prediction that Mike Huckabee will win Texas on March 4th and Mississippi on March 11th. Regardless of the primaries, I predict Mike Huckabee will be in the race for the long haul. However, I will go back on my prediction of last week that the Republican nominee will be decided last. In light of Mitt Romney’s abdication, and the delegate count being so close in the Democratic primaries, it seems clear that the Democratic nominee that will be the last chosen. To the Obama fans, you have momentum he must capitalize on it. To the Clinton supporters, you are not out of the race. You still have two out of every three super delegates leaning your way, the nomination may come down to how they vote. The Clinton’s are resourceful and I predict she will win the Texas primaries, putting her right back in the race. Either way, the Democratic contest will be the dictionary definition of a ‘political horse race’.

5 comments:

Paul said...

Will super delegates decide the democratic race and how should they vote? Should super delegates get to decide who is the nominee or should they support the person with the most delegates/states/votes?

Owen T. Carhart said...

Paul my thinking is that a deal would be brokered before either candidate let the superdelegates choose the nominee.

Brett J. Jackson said...

I hope you're right Owen, it would upset a lot of people if the superdelegates trumped the candidate with the most public support. It would make for intesting political science debate though!

neagley said...

I think this superdelegate process is going to get very sticky. Even if the Democrats are able to broker deal before the convention, I think there will be another issue. The issue with the states of Michigan and Florida are going to become a huge issue, in my opinion. Even in all of the candidates agreed to them ahead of time, I think it will get very sticky closer to the conventions.

Marc Fialkoff said...

The problem with Florida and Michigan is that these states will not pay for new primaries/caucuses and would need to go to the Credentials Committee to try and get the delegates seated. In any event, the delegates from Michigan and Florida will become a null point at the convention